Back to events

REGIONAL SCIENCE–POLICY DIALOGUE ON

Air quality management in the Indo-Gangetic Plain and Himalayan foothills

Organiser: ICIMOD and World Bank

Programmes

Atmosphere

Venue

ICIMOD headquarters, Nepal

Date & Time

14 December 2022 to 15 December 2022

Objective

The Indo-Gangetic Plain and Himalayan Foothills (IGP-HF) air quality management (AQM) science–policy dialogue  will provide a platform for the four countries sharing the IGP-HF airshed to highlight their national AQM challenges; present national and regional opportunities; find commonalities with regional partner countries; exchange knowledge; facilitate partnerships for improving monitoring, decision making, and abatement actions; and explore financing opportunities.

 

Expected outcome

The SPD is expected to strengthen awareness of the four countries of one another’s challenges and recent developments in AQM. It is also expected to contribute towards greater cooperation among the IGP-HF countries, which all share a common airshed. Concrete insights will be shared on the use of an air quality monitoring tool and the IGP-HF AQM Policy Planning tool. Furthermore, this SPD is expected to bring to the fore opportunities for regional partnerships and lead to initiatives at the regional level to tackle air pollution, which could be taken up in the World Bank’s and ICIMOD’s regional air quality engagements.

 

Background

The Indo-Gangetic Plain – spanning Bangladesh, India, Nepal, and Pakistan – has one of the most polluted airsheds in global comparison. In many places of the region, both urban and rural, air pollution has reached alarming levels, affecting the health of millions of people, particularly women, children, and the elderly; in each of these groups, the poor are the most vulnerable. The concentrations of particulate matter (PM2.5) in the region are many-fold above WHO air quality guidelines. In the IGP-HF, it is often double to triple the least stringent WHO target (i.e. Interim Target 1, which is 35 µg/m3 of annual average). There is an even larger gap to the guideline that characterises clean air (which is a value of 5 µg/m3).

The socioeconomic impact of this slow-motion disaster on the environment, human health, and society is immense. The estimated costs in health care and loss of productivity due to air pollution in Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka include 1.75 million premature deaths each year collectively in these countries, welfare losses equivalent to between 4.7% and 7.8% of GDP, depending on the country, and forgone labour output of between 0.47% and 0.8% of their GDP, depending on the country.

The largest sources of air pollution in the IGP-HF are similar for all four countries: household emissions from cookstoves, open burning of agricultural residue, industrial sources (such as brick kilns), transportation (especially diesel engines), and solid-waste burning. Hence, there is a strong imperative to foster cross-country knowledge exchanges, particularly focussing on best practices and success stories. In addition, the pollution from one country, or subnational area inside a country, may have a significant environmental and human impact elsewhere, given the transboundary nature of the air pollution challenge and the airflows across different countries. Therefore, it is vital for the countries to coordinate their monitoring, planning, and abatement design efforts.

Climate change is closely related to the air pollution challenges in these countries. The sources of air pollution mentioned above are the same sources that contribute to climate change. Moreover, much like for the air pollution challenge, the IGP-HF region also has significant climate mitigation externalities – the IGP-HF currently contributes to about 9% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Policies that reduce air pollution also simultaneously reduce short-lived climate pollutants, such as black carbon, which are of particularly potent climate forcers.

The four countries of the region have articulated their ambitions for cleaner South Asian air, in Vision 2030, during a high-level World Bank Spring Meeting event in 2021 titled ‘Solutions for Improved Air Quality and Green Recovery in South Asia’.

 

ICIMOD’s Regional Programme on Atmosphere

ICIMOD is a regional intergovernmental learning and knowledge sharing centre serving the eight Regional Member Countries of the Hindu Kush Himalayan (HKH) region – Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, India, Myanmar, Nepal, and Pakistan – and is based in Kathmandu, Nepal. Their Regional Programme on Atmosphere aims to improve understanding of air pollutant emissions, atmospheric processes and change, and impacts and promote mitigation and policy solutions while building awareness, capacity, and collaboration in the HKH and upwind regions. The programme aims to promote the adoption of effective measures and policies to reduce air pollution and its impacts within the HKH through improved knowledge and enhanced capacity of our regional partners. They engage in generating data and evidence; identifying, testing, and piloting mitigation solutions; capacity building and outreach; fostering regional collaboration and cross-border network building; and contributing to policy at local, national, regional, and global levels.

 

The World Bank’s Regional Programme on Air Pollution in the Indo-Gangetic Plain and Himalayan Foothills

The World Bank has been working on AQM in all countries of the IGP-HF. On the one hand, the World Bank has developed several air quality investment projects in different countries such as the Punjab Green Development Project (PGDP) in Pakistan and the Bangladesh Environmental Sustainability and Transformation (BEST) project. The World Bank is currently also working on developing air quality projects in several states in India, including Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Haryana. It has supported policy reforms that are critical for reducing air pollution by incentivising cleaner alternatives, such as the Green, Resilient, and Inclusive Development (GRID) Policy Credit of Nepal, where a reduction of the import costs of electric vehicles was supported.

The World Bank has also launched the development of the IGP-HF Air Quality Policy Planning tool, which is currently being piloted in several countries and will be expanded to additional countries. This tool will enable decision makers to critically understand air pollution sources in different areas of scale (from local, to national, to regional), and also the effectiveness and cost of engineering and technological solutions. Through its regional programme, the World Bank seeks to continue supporting regional dialogues, develop the IGP-HF AQM Policy Planning tool for each country in the IGP-HF (creating a nested regional tool), and work on concrete air quality solutions.

 

Agenda and objectives

The SPD will take place over two days.

Technical discussions on improving air quality management in the IGP-HF

Objectives: Day 1 will focus on the scientific and technical inputs necessary for AQM policy making in the IGP-HF. Rather than going into technical details of modelling, this session will focus on presenting initial results and identifying capacity gaps for the full development of the regional air quality policy tool. The discussions will involve the following:

  • Share technical rationale/need for enhanced local data to improve global/regional-level policy analysis tools consistent with the results of the World Bank’s flagship study ‘Striving for Clean Air’ to be shared on Day 2 (i.e. the need to move from local-AQM to airshed-AQM approach)
  • Assess current capacity for airshed-AQM planning within IGP-HF countries
  • Demonstrate the role of airshed-AQM policy tool/planning capacity in other air quality success stories (e.g. EU, China)
  • Introduce benefits of establishing IGP-HF airshed-AQM planning capacity
    • Coordinate national-level data sharing/integration
    • Integrate national-level data in a common analytical platform
    • Use common platform to inform/enhance national-level policy effectiveness
    • Serve ‘honest broker’ role in harmonising policies across borders and effecting burden-sharing to achieve uniform and equitable benefits across airshed
  • Identify common messages around airshed-AQM planning tools to table on Day 2

 

Chair: Bidya Banmali Pradhan, Regional Programme Manager, Atmosphere, ICIMOD

 

Time (NPT) Programme Speaker/facilitator
09:00–09:30 Registration
09:30–09:40 Welcome remarks Izabella Koziell, Deputy Director General, ICIMOD
09:40–09:50 Opening remarks Cecile Fruman, Director for Regional Integration and Engagement in the South Asia Region, World Bank
09:50–10:00 Round of introduction (name, designation, and affiliation)
10:00–10:05 Introduction to Day 1 Martin Heger, Senior Environmental Economist, World Bank
SESSION I: Air pollution information for decision-support at a regional (IGP-HF) scale
10:05–10:30 The state of AQM in South Asia and review of the Regional Air Quality Monitoring Tool Bhupesh Adhikary, Senior Air Quality Specialist, ICIMOD

(15 min presentation & 10 min Q&A)

10:30–10:55 Building the case for policy engagement: Building blocks for air quality decision making and success stories Jostein Nygard, Senior Environmental Specialist, World Bank

(15 min presentation & 15 min Q&A)

10:55–11:15 Tea break
Session II: Initial findings from applying the IGP-HF AQM Policy Planning tool in several IGP-HF countries, and identified gaps
11:15–11:30 Development of the IGP-HF AQM Policy Planning tool and the importance of local data, inputs, and capacity Markus Amann, Former Air Quality Programme Director of IIASA
11:30–12:00 Early findings for Bangladesh Provat K Saha, BUET, Dhaka

(20 min presentation & 10 min Q&A)

12:00–12:30 Findings for the IGP-HF states of India Sagnik Dey, IIT Delhi

(20 min presentation & 10 min Q&A)

12:30–13:30 Lunch break
Session III: Strengthening AQM Policy Planning tools in SAR: Process flow, scaling, and governance
13:30–14:00 Early results from Punjab, Pakistan Kaleem Anwar Mir, GCISC, MoCC

(20 min presentation & 10 min Q&A)

14:00–14:30 Findings from AQM studies for Nepal and challenges Anita Prajapati, Institute of Engineering, Pulchowk, Tribhuvan University

(20 min presentation & 10 min Q&A)

14:30–15:10 Making it happen: Building regional policy tools out of local data

Process flow, scaling, and governance (local, provincial, national and regional). Drawing on experience from convention on LRTAP. How important was a continuous regional dialogue and regional AQM tools in the success of LRTAP? European experience in data harmonisation, and nesting of information (from local, to national, to regional)

Representative, Task Force for Integrated Assessment Modelling, UNECE (20 min)

Discussion moderated by Jostein Nygard, Senior Environmental Specialist, World Bank (20 min)

15:10–15:30 Tea break
Session IV: Towards regional cooperation for improving IGP-HF AQM
15:30–16:15 Break-out group discussions by country: Challenges encountered in implementing IGP-HF AQM tool in each of the four countries
Group A

Bangladesh delegation

 

Moderated by Mohamed Rabi Qazizada, Programme Officer, ICIMOD, and Eun Joo Yi, Senior Environmental Specialist, World Bank

Group B

India delegation

 

Moderated by Bhupesh Adhikary, Senior Air Quality Specialist, ICIMOD, and Jostein Nygard, Senior Environmental Specialist, World Bank

Group C

Nepal delegation

 

Moderated by Siva Praveen Puppala, Programme Coordinator, ICIMOD, and Martin Heger, Senior Environmental Economist, World Bank

Group D

Pakistan delegation

 

Moderated by Bidya Banmali Pradhan, Regional Programme, ICIMOD, and Christopher James Warner, Senior Environmental Economist, World Bank

16:15–17:15 Presentation of the break-out discussions and identification of common key messages Country/state representatives:

–         Bangladesh delegation representative

–         India delegation representative

–         Nepal delegation representative

–         Pakistan delegation representative

Moderated by Martin Heger, Senior Environmental Economist, World Bank

17:15–17:20 Closing Siva Praveen Puppala, Programme Coordinator, Atmospheric Watch Initiative, ICIMOD
18:30–21:00 Reception dinner

High-level discussions on air quality management in the Indo-Gangetic Plain and Himalayan foothills

Objectives:

Day 2 will focus on high-level discussions on AQM policies in the IGP-HF. Specifically, the discussions will focus on the following:

  • Share key messages from Day 1 on the status of and need for enhanced regional AQM planning capacity and tools
  • Launch ‘Striving for Clean Air’ to reinforce key messages from Day 1
  • Demonstrate World Bank support for IGP-HF countries to undertake regional efforts to improve air quality
  • Demonstrate ICIMOD support for development of regional capacity for IGP-HF airshed AQ policy planning tool
  • Hear from IGP-HF countries on existing barriers, challenges, and needs where support could be provided by the World Bank/ICIMOD
  • Agreement on a roadmap for regional coordination/collaboration

Chair: Cecile Fruman, Director for Regional Integration and Engagement in the South Asia Region, World Bank (from beginning to 14:20) and Bidya Banmali Pradhan, Regional Programme Manager, Atmosphere, ICIMOD (from 14:20 to end)

Time (NPT) Programme Speaker/facilitator
09:00–09:30 Registration
09:30–10:00

 

Opening remarks, including ICIMOD’s air quality vision for HKH Pema Gyamtsho, Director General, ICIMOD
10:00–10:10 Recap of Day 1 and introduction of Day 2 Martin Heger, Senior Environmental Economist, World Bank

Launch of World Bank flagship study:

‘Striving for Clean Air: Air Pollution and Public Health in South Asia’

Moderated by Sahana Bajracharya, Moderator

10:15–10:17 Chairing the flagship study launch

–         Welcome

Faris Hadad-Zervos, Country Director for Maldives, Nepal, and Sri Lanka, World Bank
10:17–10:25 Opening remarks, including World Bank’s Clean Air Vision 2030 for South Asia Martin Raiser, Vice President, South Asia Region, World Bank (joining virtually)

 

10:25–10:30 Launch of World Bank flagship study  

 

10:30–10:55 Presentation of key findings the World Bank flagship study on regional air pollution in South Asia Mani Muthukumara, Lead Environmental Economist, World Bank
10:55–11:55 Moderated panel discussion on regional air quality

 

Q&A

Country representatives:

  • Md Amirul Kyser, Deputy Secretary, MOEF&CC, Bangladesh
  • Nameeta Prasad, Joint Secretary, MOEF&CC, India (TBC)
  • Namaraj Ghimire, Director General, DoE, Nepal
  • Asif Sahibzada, Director Environment Policy, MoCC, Pakistan
  • Bidya Banmali Pradhan, Regional Programme Manager, Atmosphere, ICIMOD
  • Cecile Fruman, Director for Regional Integration and Engagement in the South Asia Region, World Bank

Moderated by Sahana Bajracharya, moderator

11:55–12:00 Closing remarks Faris Hadad-Zervos, Country Director for Maldives, Nepal, and Sri Lanka, World Bank
12:00–13:00 Group photo and lunch
Regional science–policy dialogue on AQM in IGP-HF
13:00–14:20 –         What is needed for improving the AQM decision-making system?

–         Challenges and opportunities for pollution abatement (initiatives, policies, future directions)

 

Country representatives (5 min each)

Bangladesh representatives

  • Najnin Parvin, Deputy Secretary, MOEF&CC (5  min)
  • Syed Nazmul Ahsan, Director, DoE

 

India representatives

  • Nameeta Prasad, Joint Secretary, MOEF&CC (5 min)
  • Rahul Tewari, Principal Secretary, DoSTE, Punjab (5 min)
  • Roshni Sen, Principal Secretary, DoEF&CC, West Bengal (5 min)
  • Ashish Tiwari, Secretary, DoEF&CC, Uttar Pradesh (5 min)

 

Nepal representatives

  • Namaraj Ghimire, Director General, DoE (5 min)

 

Pakistan representatives

  • Asif Sahibzada, Director Environment Policy, MOCC (5 min)
  • Samia Saleem, Additional Secretary, EPD, Punjab (5 min)

 

Moderated by Cecile Fruman, Director for Regional Integration and Engagement in the South Asia Region, World Bank

14:20–15:00 World Bank & ICIMOD engagements on air quality in IGP-HF countries Gailius Draugelis, Operations Manager, Pakistan, World Bank

Hideki Mori, Operations Manager, World Bank, India

Dandan Chen, Acting Country Director, Bangladesh

Bidya Banmali Pradhan, Regional Programme Manager, Atmosphere, ICIMOD

15:00–15:15 Tea break
15:15–15:45 The case for regional coordination in AQM:

–         Cross-border airflows

–         Mutual benefits

–         Incentives and collaboration structures

What is needed to get to more regional coordination:

–         Establish communities of practice across countries

–         Regional science–policy platform

–         Harmonised data and policy planning tool adoption

Markus Amann, Former Director of the Air Quality Programme, IIASA

 

Q&A

15:45–17:00 Introduction to the roadmap for AQM regional coordination (by World Bank)

Brief remarks on and endorsement of the agreements for regional AQM coordination

Signing of the Kathmandu roadmap by countries (facilitated by ICIMOD)

Way forward and next steps (ICIMOD and World Bank)

Pema Gyamtsho, Director General, ICIMOD

 

Christophe Crepin, Manager, Environment, Natural Resources and Blue Economy Global Practice in South Asia, World Bank (joining virtually)

 

Country representatives

 

 

17:00–17:10 Closing remarks Pema Gyamtsho, Director General, ICIMOD